follow me on Twitter

    Tuesday, April 8, 2008

    Tom Hafey and Kevin Bartlett respond to the criticism of Punt Road

    - By Rhett Bartlett
    Exclusive to www.rhettrospective.com

    Tom Hafey's style of football was always direct. So much so, that it won him 4 Premierships across 7 years as coach for Richmond.

    And his response to the claims by Andrew Dememtriou in The Age to Caroline Wilson that Punt Road was 'a crap ground to train on. It's just a bad ground and it's the wrong size.' was almost as direct.

    'That's a ridiculous statement. I think that is wrong, I don't think it is crap' Hafey said when contacted by www.rhettrospective.com this afternoon.

    'They talk this way because they play on perfect grounds- yet the number of players that continue to slip on perfect ground is amazing'
    '(Punt Road) is a long way better that alot of other teams have to deal with. The ground still is perfect as a training facility.


    Tommy should know, for many years he has travelled the breadth of Australia, coaching junior clubs and guest speaking at little known towns. 'How would they (footballers) go playing in Queenstown- it's just gravel!' 'Remember that Docklands was rubbished initially too! and most recently Collingwood and Brisbane played in mud and rain at the Gabba. It won't always be perfect weather and grounds wont always be perfect- regardless if it is in Western Australia or Sydney'

    When pressed further regarding suggestions that the ground size, may be consider a reasoning behind Richmond's lack of success- Hafey was adamant 'It has got nothing to do with it!' - citing instead an imbalance in the handballing and kicking stats of the Tigers on the weekend.
    In no way, Hafey suggested, does the condition of the Punt Road ground directly relate to the Tigers performance on match day.

    And 5 time Premiership player Kevin Bartlett feels the same, 'We never trained at the MCG, we trained at Punt Road, and in my opinion it never affected the Richmond style of play. It never ever impeded the Richmond style of play- and we were the longest kicking, fast kicking ball side in the competition and we trained at Punt Road.

    He points out that other teams around his time of playing and coach, played on smaller grounds:
    Go down and have a look at Hawthorn's old ground at Glenferrie Oval- it is the smallest ground in the world and they won premierships galore!

    Suggesting that Richmond's lack of success lately is due to the state of the Punt Road Ground is something Bartlett disagrees with: 'It certainly wouldn't be an excuse! Training at Punt Road wont stop you from winning a premiership.'

    And although the glorious ancient ground herself is unable to defend these Demetriou comments- there are still some Immortals who are more than happy to.

    - by Rhett Bartlett

    Sunday, April 6, 2008

    David King Rd 3 Post Match Comments

    as interviewed on 3AW.
    transcribed www.rhettrospective.com

    'we gave Collingwood too much at the start. You can't give good sides 7 of the first 8 scoring shots and expect to be in the game. You got to know when the right time to kick and when your out in space and able to execute them and that's something our players are getting wrong. We've made adjustments to the way we wanted to play from last year and sure that involves an element of handball but we've got the balance wrong at the moment- i think we have 170 odd kicks and over 200 handballs.

    Even in saying that, we still shouldn't have made errors by foot that we did.
    I think alot of the backline boys are coming along quite nicely , I think people would credit Will Thursfield to have improved, I think they would have seen that in Jake King , although he hasn't a great last fortnight, he has certainly improved. I think Kel Moore has become a player, Jay Schulz was good again today, he's had an up and down career but he's improving.
    Teams that are winning , individual form doesn't come into it. If your disciplined enough to stick to the team plans then individual form doesn't come into it.

    You recruit good kickers, you either have got that skill or haven't . It's a waste of time trying to get players who can't kick, back to square one and start again because the man hours involved in that is not available to AFL players at the moment.
    I just thought today, we talked about stepping back inside , and cutting and taking players on- not once were we brave enough to take people on, we were too straight minded earlier today and it made us pay.'

    Sunday, March 30, 2008

    Rich vs Coll Rd 3 Live Blog

    Live Blogging of Rich vs Coll.
    To replay it click the button below.
    Any feedback please email rhettrospective@hotmail.com

    A reminder that RICHMOND vs FREMANTLE will be blogged live here, next Sunday @ 4.30pm (EST). We invite you all to join in on the live Richmond blog then.


    Richmond vs Nth Results

    Richmond vs Nth Melbourne
    4.40pm @ MCG

    Richmond 3.1 / 7.4 / 10.7 / 13.8.86
    Nth Melb 7.4 / 11.4/ 18.5 / 20.7.127

    Goals: Schulz 3.0, Richardson 2.3 , Hughes 1.2 , Simmonds 1.1 , Deledio 1.1 , Hyde 1.0 King 1.0 , Foley 1.0 , Brown 1.0 , Tuck 1.0

    Notes:
    Matthew Richardson kicks his 750th career goal during the second quarter.

    Andrew Raines leaves the field with a dislocated knee cap.

    This is billed as the 'Eureka Match' in honour of the men and women of the workforce throughout the last centenary.

    Terry Wallace Post Match Comments for Round 2 vs Nth Melbourne

    'The one thing I would like to say to our supporter base is just the fact last year we lost games and had a pretty ordinary season and at times we couldn't do anything about it , we just didn't have the blokes up and running and we had to go with the same blokes who let us down week in week out.

    I just want to let our supporter base know that we are fully fit and healthy , we've got blokes running around at Coburg- our side won by over 10 goals yesterday against the reigning Premiers.

    Blokes who don't respect their position in the side , therfore don't respect the guernsey, won't play.

    Therefore we are in a position where we can do that and we will make changes to the side til we have the right blokes in there who want to compete, so I think that supporters shouldn't walk away thinking they are going to get the same old same old, because we will throw it around and give the young blokes an opportunity until we get the right blokes in there who want to compete.

    'Collingwood have a longer break this week, so we have to come off a 7 , versus a 9 day break this week. We like it to be a 6 day break ourselves so we can get back there straight-away.

    'We were getting beaten at ground level. Clearly our boys in the midfield are extremley disappointed with their efforts, they know that , they understand that and they don't accept that but they were clearly beaten around that area and it just put pressure on every area of that game from that stage onwards. We were really smashed in that part of the game today.

    We started Andrew Raines on Corey Jones at the start of the game and wanted Rainesy to do the job and he got beaten in the first few contests and then we went to Jake King as our secondary option, we had sort of set Raines for that job all week, and it didn't work, so you have got to make changes. Jake has been able to play on taller players, he played as a Coburg player at Centre Half Back most of the time, so he has always been able to play on blokes a little bit taller than him. Corey was in fantastic form, I think he was trying to get two weeks out of one after missing last week, and credit to him I thought he played tremendously.

    We think Raines dislocated his knee cap but it certainly went back in. It's just a matter of how that sort of settles down over the next few days. We will have to wait til tomorrow to find out where he is at.'

    - Terry Wallace post match press conference versus Nth Melbourne, courtesy of rhettrospective.com

    Richmond vs Nth Melb- Rd 2- the live blog

    The live blog for Richmond vs Nth Melbourne has finished.
    But you can replay it anytime by clicking the play button below.

    Thank you to all those who participated in the live blog, we were live around the world including Japan, London, Dubai, QLD, Tassie, South Yarra (lol), Maribyrnong, Newcastle...

    And thanks to members from yellowandblack, puntroadend and bigfooty for their assistance.

    Join us for the live blog of Richmond vs Collingwood next Sunday 6th April
    @ 2pm(Melbourne time)

    All feedback regarding the live blog below can be sent to rhettrospective@hotmail.com


    Friday, March 21, 2008

    Carlton vs Richmond Rd 1 2008

    Thursdy, March 20, 2008 @ MCG 6.10pm
    72,552

    1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
    C: 4.3-27 , 9.6-60 , 10.10-70 11.13-79
    R: 4.3-27 , 8.5-53, 11.5-71, 17.7-109

    Goals: Richmond: Matthew Richardson 5.2, Nathan G Brown 3, Brett Deledio 2, Kayne Pettifer, Shane Tuck, Adam Pattison, Nathan Foley, Graham Polak, Daniel Jackson, Richard Tambling.

    Carlton: Brendan Fevola 2, Eddie Betts 2, Heath Scotland 2, Marc Murphy, Setanta O'hAilpin, Nick Stevens, Ryan Houlihan, Jake Edwards.

    Reports:
    Cameron Howat (Rch) was cited with a Level Four striking offence against Adam Hartlett (Car) during Q3.
    The MRP offered Howat a two-match suspension with an early plea.
    Richmond sought the adjudication of the Tribunal. The Tribunal found Howat guilty and suspended him for three matches.
    (courtesy of footystats)

    Notes:
    Matthew Richardson rises to equal 12th on the League all-time goalkicking list with 748 goals from 257 games (with Saverio Rocca - same goals and matches played)

    Richmond and Carlton meet for the 200th time in VFL History.

    Tuesday, March 18, 2008

    Richmond Hall of Fame 2008

    3 players were inducted into the Richmond Hall of Fame on Monday 17 March 2008, along with the elevation of Royce Hart into the Immortal category.

    1932 /1934 Premiership Player KEVIN O'NEILL


    1980 Premiership Player JIM JESS


    1980 Premiership Player GEOFF RAINES

    Rich vs Geelong - Friday 7th Match

    Challenge Match @ Skilled Stadium

    GEELONG 6.2 14.9 20.9 23.11 (149)
    RICHMOND 3.0 5.1 6.3 12.5 (77)

    GOALS
    Geelong: Mooney 4, Gamble 3, Byrnes 2, Ablett 2, Bartel 2, S Johnson 2, Ling 2, Corey 2, Hawkins, Wojcinski, Prismall, Blake, Mackie

    Richmond: Richardson 3, Morton 2, Deledio 2, Coughlan, Howat, White, Hughes, Foley

    BEST
    Ling, Bartel, Kelly, Mackie, Prismall, Byrnes, S Johnson, Enright.
    Richmond: King, Tuck.

    Friday, February 29, 2008

    Richmond vs Swans - Challenge Cup 29th Feb 08

    Venue: Narrandera Sportsground
    Time: 7pm
    Crowd: 8,296

    Richmond: 5.5 / 10.7 / 15.8 / 17.11.113
    Swans: 3.3 / 7.7 / 11.9 / 13.10.88

    Goals:

    Richmond: Richardson 5, Deledio 3, Johnson 2, Hughes 1, Tuck 1, Polak 1, Pettifer 1, Tambling 1, Brown 1, White 1

    Sydney Swans: Hall 4, Bolton 2, McVeigh, Jolly, Kirk, O'Loughlin, Moore, O'Keefe, Ablett


    Team: Richardson, Deledio, Simmonds, Brown, Schultz, Pettifer, Hughes, Johnson (c), Tuck, White, McMahon, Newman, Foley, Thursfield, Pattison, Collins, Tambling, Polak.


    Notes: Robert Dipierdomenico was present as part of the AFL's 150th Celebration
    Schultz stretched off after sustaining a cracked rib during a goalsquare pack, reports suggested he collided with Richardson.
    Polak injures his foot.

    Sunday, February 24, 2008

    NAB Challenge Match vs Melbourne (Feb 22nd)

    Richmond defeat Melbourne at Cazaly Stadium in their NAB Challenge Match, by 35 points

    Rich 5.3 / 6.4 / 115.71 / 14.10.94
    Melb 2.3 / 5.5 / 6.9.45 / 8.11.59

    Goals:
    Richmond: Pettifer 3, Schulz 2, Hughes 2, C Howat 2, A Pattison N Foley M Morton N Brown A Raines.
    Melbourne: M Newton 2 C Bartram R Petterd B Green A Maric I Weetra A Davey.

    Best:
    Richmond: K Pettifer C Newman T Simmonds R Tambling N Foley J Bowden.
    Melbourne: C Newton N Jones A Davey C Sylvia P Johnson S Valenti.

    Umpires: C Kamolins J Armstrong H Kennedy.

    Attendace: 5,321 people.

    NAB CUP MATCH vs StKilda (Feb 15th)

    A disappointing Richmond team lose to StKilda by 40 points at Docklands.

    StK: 0.4.0.1.25 /1.7.0.5.56 /1.11.1.6.84 /1.15.1.9.111
    Ric: 0.3.0.2.20 /0.4.0.4.28 /2.6.0.7.61 /2.7.0.11.71

    Goals:
    Richmond: 9pts: Greg Tivendale, Chris Newman.
    Richmond 6pts: Brett Deledio 2, Nathan G Brown 2, Matthew Richardson, Kayne Pettifer, Mitch Morton.

    Best:
    Matthew Richardson, Shane Tuck, Chris Newman, Kayne Pettifer, Joel Bowden, Nathan G Brown.

    Richmond Squad:
    Chris Newman, Brett Deledio, Andrew Raines, Troy Simmonds, Graham Polak, Nathan Brown, Jack Riewoldt, Shane Edwards, Joel Bowden, Matthew Richardson, Jordan McMahon, Kayne Pettifer, Kane Johnson, Mitch Morton, Shane Tuck, Daniel Jackson, Jay Schulz, Adam Pattison, Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls, Richard Tambling, Chris Hyde, Greg Tivendale, Jarrod Silvester, Travis Casserly, Tristan Cartledge, Kelvin Moore, Nathan Foley, Jake King.

    Notes:
    Umpire Darren Goldspink officates he last ever game of AFL Football.

    Matthew Richardson kicks Richmonds' first behind, and their first goal.

    In the 1st quarter, Richardson receives a 50 metre penalty on the wing, and his resulting kick for goal hits the post. (it would have been a 9 point goal)- but Deledio roving the rebound off the post kicks a 6pt goal.

    Tuesday, February 19, 2008

    Coburg Practice Match

    On Sunday 16th February, Coburg played Geelong Reserves in a practice match at Skilled Stadium at 1.30pm.


    Notes:
    4 x 20 min quarters no time on.
    Rance injures his ankle.

    Up to 12 Richmond players play for Coburg in this match.
    (Howat, Coughlan,White, Polo, Schultz, Collins, Thursfield, Hughes, Putt, Collard, Gourdis, Rance)

    Coburg: 5.3 / ???? / ???? / ????
    Geelong: 1.4 / ???? / ???? / ????

    Friday, February 15, 2008

    Intra-Club Match @ Echuca

    On February 7th 2008- Richmond played an intra-club match at Echuca - Jack Eddy Oval @ 4pm

    Notes:
    White Team coached by David King.
    Nathan Brown was rested from the game, because Terry Wallace was 'paranoid' about him playing before the Round 1 match.
    Attendance: 2,000
    10 players from the Echuca area were given the opportunity to play in the match. They were:

    Liam Guinan (Echuca), Troy Muir (Echuca), John Foskett (Moama), Damien Dalziel (Echuca United), Nick Iorianni (Echuca United), Luke Dunham (Moama), Craig Frost (Echuca United), Duane Hueston (Echuca United), Thomas McKitterick (Echuca) and Chris Casey (Echuca) all played.


    Blacks: 3.3 / 5.6 / ???? / 12.10.82
    Whites: 6.1 / 8.8 / ???? / 18.10.118

    Goalkickers:
    Majority of goalkickers have yet to be sourced. However below, are some that are noted.
    Hughes 4 (3 in first quarter), Collard 3 (all in 3rd term), Deledio 3, Luke Dunham 1.
    Richardson 2

    Notes:
    Mark Coughlan plays his first competitive game of football since his knee injury in Round 12 2006.

    Wednesday, February 6, 2008

    RFC Book Signing - Feb 15th w/ KB and Tom Hafey




    The book signing will occur at the Angus and Robertson Bookstore on the corner of
    Elizabeth St and Bourke St from 12.30pm - 1.30pm on February 15th.

    Monday, February 4, 2008

    Richmond Records 1970-1975

    As you know, I have written the RFC 2008 Centenary Publication called 'The Tigers'- and more recently, another of my pastimes is to collect Richmond Football Records.

    So, I thought it only best to list below, the records I am missing from the 1970's- and if anyone has any they wish to sell, then feel free to contact me at rhettrospective@hotmail.com Here to start off are the records I am missing from 1970-1975.

    1970
    rd 1 apr 4-5
    rd 3 apr 18
    rd 5 may 2
    rd 6 may 9
    rd 10 june 6
    rd 13 june 27
    rd 16 july 18
    rd 19 aug 8

    1971
    rd 6 may 8
    rd 7 may 15
    rd 8 may 22
    rd 11 june 14
    rd 20 aug 14

    1972
    rd 4 apr 22
    rd 6 may 6
    rd 8 may 20
    rd 11 june 10
    rd 15 jul 15
    rd 16 jul 22
    rd 22 sep 22

    1973
    rd 1 apr 7
    rd 3 apr 21
    rd 8 may 26
    rd 10 june 9
    rd 11 june 16
    rd 18 aug 4
    rd 20 aug 18

    1974
    rd 5 may 4
    rd 7 may 18
    rd 10 jun 8
    Rd 13 jun 29
    rd 15 jul 13
    rd 22 aug 31

    1975
    rd 1 apr 5
    rd 6 may 10
    rd 9 may 31
    rd 10 jun 7
    rd 12 jun 21
    rd 15 jul 12
    rd 16 jul 19
    rd 18 aug 2
    rd 19 aug 9
    rd 20 aug 16
    rd 21 aug 23
    rd 22 aug 30

    Saturday, February 2, 2008

    Intra-Club Practice Match #2



    Richmond and selected Coburg players play an intra club match at Gosch's Paddock from 10.00am on
    Friday February 1st 2008.

    Rules: 2 x quarters. Yellows vs Blacks.
    Weather: Blustery

    The selected teams are listed below , albeit incomplete.

    Yellows:
    Riewoldt, Polo, Rance, Putt, Coughlan, Schulz, Collard, Hyde, White, Silvester, Moore, Collins, King, Stewart, Polak, Gazzo (#29)

    Blacks:

    Newman, Raines, Edwards (#35), Morton, Tuck, Jackson, Pattison, Oakley-Nicholls, Hughes, Gourdis, Casserly, Cartledge, Polak

    Scores (incomplete)
    Yellows: 2.2 / 10/5/65
    Blacks 4.6 / 6.8.44

    Goals (incomplete)
    Yellow: Polak (2), Collins (2), Chris Stewart (2), Riewoldt (1), (#3 unknown), (#31 unknown), (#36 unknown)

    Blacks: Morton (2.5), Casserly (1), Polak (1), Hughes (1), Edwards (1).

    Notes:
    Polak may have switched sides to the 'Yellow' team at the break.
    Moore may have injured calf (awaiting confirmation)



    source: oneeyedrichmond (http://oneeyed-richmond.com/forum//index.php?topic=6459.0)
    yellowandblack.

    Friday, January 25, 2008

    2008 Player List.

    The 2008 Richmond Player List.

    V = Veteran List

    Bowden, Joel (V)
    Brown, Nathan G.
    Casserly, Travis
    Collins, Andrew
    Connors, Daniel
    Cotchin, Trent
    Coughlan, Mark
    Deledio, Brett
    Edwards, Shane
    Foley, Nathan
    Gourdis, David
    Graham, Angus
    Hughes, Cleve
    Hyde, Chris
    Jackson, Daniel
    Johnson, Kane
    King, Jake
    McGuane, Luke
    McMahon, Jordan
    Meyer, Danny
    Moore, Kelvin
    Morton, Mitch
    Newman, Chris
    Oakley-Nicholls, Jarrad
    Pattison, Adam
    Pettifer, Kayne
    Polak, Graham
    Polo, Dean
    Putt, Dean
    Raines, Andrew
    Rance, Alex
    Richardson, Matthew (V)
    Riewoldt, Jack
    Schulz, Jay
    Simmonds, Troy
    Tambling, Richard
    Thursfield, Will
    Tivendale, Greg
    Tuck, Shane
    White, Matthew

    ROOKIES
    Cartledge, Tristan
    Collard, Clayton
    Howat, Cam
    Silvester, Jarrod

    source: footystats.

    Intra-Club Practice Match #1

    Richmond held its first practice match for season 2008.

    Venue: Gosch's Paddock @10.15am (25/1/08)
    Match Rules: 2 x quarters of football approximately 25-30 minutes each.

    Blacks: 6.1. 37 / 13.4.82
    Yellows: 4.6.30 / 10.6.66

    Goals:
    Blacks: Polo 2, Pettifer 2, Hyde 2, Putt 1, Tivendale 1, Jackson 1, Edwards 1, Schulz 1, Brown 1. Unknown 1.

    Yellows: Collard 3, Riewoldt 2, Tuck 1, McMahon 1, Foley 1, Johnson 1, Collins 1.

    Team:
    Yellows:
    Raines (4), Riewoldt (8), Richardson (12), McMahon (28), Johnson (17), Putt (19), Morton, Tuck (21), Pattison (26), Collard (27),
    Tambling (30), Collins (33), White (36), Moore (40), Foley (41).

    Black:
    Polak (6), Brown (7), Edwards (10), Polo (14), Pettifer (15), Rance (18), Jackson (23), Coghlan (24), Schulz (25), Oakley-Nicholls (29), Hyde (31), Tivendale (32), Hughes (34), Casserly (37), Gourdis (42), Silvester (20), Cartledge, King (46)

    Notes:

    Richard Tambling is injured during the last quarter of the match after being tackled into the ground by Oakley-Nicholls. His injury is initially reported on radio as a knee injury. He had however injured the arch of his ankle.

    Deledio, Simmonds and Newman acted as boundary umpires.

    Newman , McGuane, Meyer acted as goal umpires.

    Howat, Connors, Graham, Cotchin acted as statisticians



    Sources: oneeyed-richmond, puntroadend. bigfooty

    Saturday, January 5, 2008

    Vale Clinton Grybas



    Respected media commentator CLINTON GRYBAS died today at his home in Melbourne.

    Clinton was the main sports reporter on 3AW, and had hosted White Line Fever on the FOX Footy Channel on FOXTEL.
    He also commentated the football for the 2007 Season on both 3AW and Fox Sports.

    On a personal note, I had met Clinton several times during my father's time on the FOX Footy Channel. I found him to be the most considerate, sincere and genuine person you could meet. A true comet of broadcast has died.

    Clinton was 32 years old. Only 32.